"If I'd Been The One"
A heartbroken ballad, lost inside an empty space. The speaker wrestles with regret, wondering if saying goodbye instead would've spared the pain. Asking for empathy, can their former love understand the hidden tears behind the smile? Haunting melody echoes the longing, a poignant exploration of "what if" in a failed relationship.
- CATEGORY: All Time Favorite Music
- BAND: .38 Special
- GENRE: Southern rock, Hard rock
- YEAR: 1984
"If I'd Been The One" by .38 Special is a 1984 power ballad pulsating with regret and introspection. The song paints a picture of a man haunted by a lost love, questioning every decision that led to their parting.
It opens with him feeling "lost inside, empty space in my heart," grappling with the unchanging pain of the breakup. He begs his ex to "read my mind" and understand the turmoil hidden beneath his forced smile. The heart of the song is the agonizing "what if": what if he'd been the one to end things, would she be able to hide her heartbreak too?
The instrumental, with its prominent piano and soaring guitar solos, mirrors the emotional rollercoaster. The verses are melancholic, punctuated by driving drumbeats, while the chorus explodes with raw yearning and the desperate plead, "If I'd been the one to say goodbye, goodbye / Could you smile when inside you just want to cry?"
By the final verse, the man accepts his role in the downfall, admitting, "Maybe I held back too tight, too long / Never let you fly, never sang your song." The song ends with a fading echo of "If I'd been the one," leaving the listener with a lingering sense of sorrow and the weight of the unspoken truth.